Guide

Guides · Before you submit

Check references before you submit a paper

Journals and conferences are rejecting manuscripts over references that do not exist. The check belongs with the other pre-submission jobs: figures, ethics, and the reference list. Do it while you can still delete a line.

Paste references and check themReferences

Submitting opens RefCheck and starts a check. 3 free reference checks without an account, plus 5 more free after you sign in. The text is placed in the web address; paste into the full checker if you would rather not do that. One reference per line. For a long list, use the full checker so the text is not put in the address.

A short list to finish before upload

Paste the reference list that will actually go in the file, not an earlier draft. For each line, keep it only if the verdict is real, or if you have fixed a “real with errors” line from the corrected citation. Remove “likely fabricated” lines. Do not submit “unconfirmed” lines that you have not opened yourself.

Read every retraction flag. A paper can match perfectly and still be the wrong thing to cite as support. The notice, when RefCheck has a DOI for it, is linked from Crossref (Retraction Watch), PubMed, or Europe PMC.

Then do the step the tool cannot do: for any sentence that reports a number, a causal claim, or a “studies show,” open the matched paper and confirm it says that. RefCheck stops at the bibliographic record.

Where invented references enter a manuscript

They enter when a chat tool drafts the related work, when a citation manager is fed a made-up DOI, and when a line is copied from another paper that was itself unchecked. The style of the journal, APA or IEEE or Vancouver, does not protect you. Run the checker on the list you will submit.

ICLR’s program chairs have described desk-rejecting submissions with confirmed references to documents that do not exist. That episode is written up under citation incidents. The practical lesson is to check before review, not after a desk reject.

Limits to tell a coauthor

RefCheck queries public scholarly databases: Crossref, OpenAlex, Semantic Scholar, and, by type, PubMed, Europe PMC, arXiv, DBLP, DataCite, Open Library, and Google Books. A Chinese-only journal article often stays unconfirmed and is linked out to CNKI, Wanfang, and Baidu Scholar. A missing record is not always a fake paper. A found record is not always the version you read.

3 free reference checks without an account, plus 5 more free after you sign in. Then 1 credit each. Failed lookups are refunded.

Typical cases

The related-work section was drafted last

That is where unchecked lines accumulate. Paste that section’s references even if the rest of the bibliography came from a citation manager.

A coauthor used a chatbot and cleaned the prose

Editing the sentences does not repair the references. Check the list they added.

The venue asked for a numbered style

Change the style after the existence check, or check again if a reference manager rewrote DOIs while it reformatted.

How it works

Three steps for this kind of reference

01Paste

One reference per line, or a numbered list. Keep the authors, title, year, and the DOI or arXiv id if you have them.

02Cross-check

The submitted list is matched and retraction-checked. You still confirm that each kept paper supports the sentence you attached to it.

03Read the verdict

Real, real with errors, likely fabricated, or unconfirmed. A corrected citation is shown when the record disagrees, and a retraction is flagged when one is on record.

Related pages

Frequently asked questions

Will a journal run this for me?

Some venues now screen references, and some do not. A desk reject is a bad time to discover a fabricated line. Check the list you are about to upload.

Does a real verdict mean I can submit?

It means the record matched. You still need the paper to support the claim, and you still need to read any retraction notice.

What should I do with unconfirmed?

Open the work yourself or delete the line. Do not leave a stack of unconfirmed references in a submitted PDF and hope the index was incomplete.

Does reformatting to the journal’s style require another check?

Check again if the formatter changed DOIs, years, or page ranges. Punctuation changes alone do not create a new paper, but tools sometimes swap identifiers while they restyle.

What does a check cost?

3 free reference checks without an account, plus 5 more free after you sign in. Then each reference costs 1 AILatest credit. Failed lookups are refunded. Credits last 1 year and the expiry extends on every top-up. Packs are $1.99 for 200, $4.99 for 600, and $9.99 for 1,500. There is no subscription.

Cite only what's real.

3 free reference checks without an account, plus 5 more free after you sign in. Then 1 credit each.